top of page

Egypt charter opens road for Sisi but youths alienated (JMD quote)

Egypt charter opens road for Sisi but youths alienated

By Mona Salem and Jay Deshmukh

5 hours ago

Cairo (AFP) - The approval of Egypt's constitution bolsters the powerful army chief but a large number of youths who helped topple two presidents within three years shunned the vote on the new charter.

Sisi led the overthrow of Islamist president Mohamed Morsi in July following massive protests against his one-year rule, which came after an uprising in 2011 toppled his predecessor Hosni Mubarak. Egyptian voters have approved the Tuesday-Wednesday referendum by 98.1 percent, officials announced Saturday, and the results are seen as nod to General Abdel Fattah al-Sisi to run for president.

Youth movements at the forefront of protests that ended the rules of Morsi and Mubarak hardly objected when the military-installed authorities launched a deadly crackdown on Morsi's supporters.

Nor did they object when his Muslim Brotherhood movement was banned and designated a "terrorist" organisation.

But they voiced their outrage when the military-backed authorities passed a law in November banning unauthorised demonstrations.

And this appears to have been clearly reflected during the voting.

Polling station officials count ballots in the Egyptian capital Cairo on January 15, 2014 (AFP Photo …

Sisi had urged the youths to participate in the referendum, saying they formed "more than 50 percent" of Egypt's 85-million strong population.

But AFP reporters who toured polling stations said youths did not participate in the voting in strength and analysts confirmed many young people clamouring for change shunned the polls.

Political analyst Hassan Nafea said turnout was "disappointing".

"The youth refused to participate in the referendum because they consider what is happening as a counter-revolution to the January revolution (against Hosni Mubarak)," Nafea said.

Electoral commission head Nabil Salib announced the results on Saturday and said turnout "reached 38.6 percent" of 53 million registered voters, with only 1.9 percent voting "no."

Salib also acknowledged a certain percentage of youths had not voted as the referendum coincided with exams, otherwise "turnout would have been higher".

Egyptians celebrate in Tahrir square after a new constitution was approved on January 18, 2014 in Ca …

But Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood said in a statement young voters "were not busy with exams, but busy with demonstrations against the coup d'etat and the invalid referendum".

The new charter replaces an Islamist-inspired one adopted in a December 2012 referendum under Morsi with about two-thirds of the vote and a 33 percent turnout.

Nafea said the result showed, however, support for Sisi to run for president because "a large segment of Egyptians see the Brotherhood as a threat to the society".

Spectre of Mubarak era

Sisi has said he would run for the presidency if there was a popular demand.

The general is wildly popular with the millions who took to the streets against Morsi, but the Islamist's followers revile him for what they say was a "coup" against Egypt's first freely elected president.

A handout picture released by the Egyptian Ministry of Defence shows Egypt's military chief Abde …

The Brotherhood, reeling from a crackdown by the military-installed authorities that has seen thousands of Islamists arrested and more than 1,000 people killed, dismissed the referendum as a "farce".

Many youths agreed, but for different reasons.

"For us it is ironic that the constitution talks of freedom of speech and yet those who said no to the constitution have been jailed," said activist Mohamed Ghorab of the No to Military Trials of Civilians group.

"For many this is a reminder of the previous Mubarak era regime," he said.

Prominent youth leaders from the 2011 uprising against Mubarak have been jailed in recent weeks.

They include Ahmed Maher, Ahmed Douma and Mohamed Adel, convicted in December for organising an unlicensed protest -- days after a law was passed in November banning all but police-sanctioned demonstrations.

These convictions have been denounced by rights groups and experts who says they threaten the gains achieved since the toppling of Mubarak and signal a return of a police state.

Youths have also been angered by a flurry of reports in the local media that gave unflattering accounts of their role in the 2011 uprising.

Such articles, said the analyst Nafea, are seen by the youths as "an attempt to steal the June 30 revolution (against Morsi) for the benefit" of Mubarak cronies.

The non-Islamist youngsters "who participated in the revolt against Mubarak did not do that for a return to autocracy," said James Dorsey of Singapore's S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies.

"They are asking questions, and the question is whether the new regime will believe in liberal politics and there is no indication that it is going to do so," he added.

On Sunday, in an apparent attempt to appease young Egyptians, interim president Adly Mansour said "the youths... were the engine of two popular revolutions".

"But your role is not over yet... continue on the path and get involved in the political life... you know that freedoms are now guaranteed," he said live on state television.

2 views0 comments


bottom of page