top of page

History repeats itself with the assassination of a Hamas official

James M. Dorsey



The Turbulent World with James M. Dorsey depends on the support of its readers. If you believe that the column and podcast add value to your understanding and that of the broader public, please consider becoming a paid subscriber by clicking on the subscription button at http://www.jamesmdorsey.substack.com and choosing one of the subscription options. Thank you.

An audio podcast is available on Soundcloud.



Please Subscribe


History repeats itself.


Palestinian airplane hijackings and attacks on Israeli civilians in Israel as well as on Israeli and Jewish targets abroad pockmarked the 1970s and 1980s.


A Swissair plane in September 1970 was hijacked by the PFLP and brought with two other planes to Dawson’s Field in the Jordanian desert. (AFP)


The violence put the Palestinian issue on the world agenda. The violence erupted, and at times, was driven by fierce debate among Palestinian guerilla leaders on whether to drop maximalist demands for replacing the State of Israel with a (Palestinian-dominated) “secular democratic state” and strive for a Palestinian state alongside Israel.

It took the PLO 16 years to unambiguously accept Israel’s existence and end armed resistance against Israel in 1988.

The violence ebbed and flowed. It involved targeted assassinations of Israeli and Palestinian representatives and leaders in third countries.

The 1982 shooting in London of the Israeli ambassador to Britain, Shlomo Argov, sparked the Israeli invasion of Lebanon and forced Yasser Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organisation to decamp from Lebanon to Tunisia.


Crime Scene Attempted Assassination of Shlomo Argov, the Israeli ambassador to the United Kingdom, Thursday 3rd June 1982. Photo: Bunny Atkins/Mirropix/Getty Images

 

For much of the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, Israel refused to engage with the PLO, employing the same language it uses today about Hamas.


To be sure, Hamas’ October 7 attack on Israel upped the ante in scale and brutality.

It has, again fitting a historic pattern, empowered the most extreme ultra-nationalist, ultra-religious elements on Israel’s political spectrum, and sparked a war, involving indiscriminate bombing and punishment of a civilian population that Israel and Hamas will find difficult to live down.


While the jury is out, the war has not halted a torturous process within Hamas, much like the equally torturous evolution within the PLO.


Hamas’ internal debate became evident with the adoption of its 2017 amended charter and has continued despite the war. There is no guarantee that Hamas will follow in the footsteps of the PLO.


This week’s presumably Israeli killing in Beirut of senior Hamas official Saleh al-Arouri, a 57-year-old co-founder of the group’s military wing, the Izz al-Din al-Qassam Brigades, and deputy head of its political bureau, raises the spectre of renewed tit-for-tat Palestinian and Israeli killings in third countries with one difference.


Hamas deputy political chief Saleh al-Arouri, after signing a reconciliation deal with senior Fatah official Azzam al-Ahmad, during a short ceremony at the Egyptian intelligence complex in Cairo, Egypt. Photo: AP/Nariman El-Mofty

 

Mr. Al-Arouri, was widely viewed as a hardliner within Hamas, responsible for the group’s military infrastructure in Lebanon and operations on the West Bank, where its popularity is on the rise because of the Gaza war and its contribution to a potentially burgeoning armed insurgency.


Protests erupted on the West Bank, in response to calls by Hamas for “acts of resistance,” to protest the killing of Mr. Al-Arouri, a West Bank native, and several other Hamas operatives in the Beirut drone strike. A general strike closed down businesses.


In August, Mr. Al-Arouri telegraphed Hamas’s intentions long before the October 7 attack.

“A total war has become inevitable. We all consider it necessary… The resistance axis, the Palestinian people, and our nation, we want this total war. It is not (just) something we say in the media. We talk about it behind closed doors…. We are discussing together the different scenarios and possibilities,” Mr. Al-Arouri told Al Maydeen TV.


Last century’s tit-for-tat killings of Palestinians targeted primarily PLO moderates, not hardliners, and were perpetrated not only by Israel but also by Palestinian hardliners, like Abu Nidal, a renegade PLO operative.


Israel has repeatedly warned that it will hunt down Hamas operatives wherever they are.

In 2015, the US State Department offered up to $5 million for “information leading to the identification or location” of Mr. Al-Arouri.


Even so, Israel failed to notify the Biden administration of its plans to take out Mr. Al-Arouri, a sign it feared the US would oppose the operation because it risked expanding the war beyond carefully calibrated hostilities on the Lebanese-Israeli border and in the Red Sea as well as Israeli-Palestinian clashes in the West Bank.


Complicating the fallout of Mr. Al-Arouri’s death is the fact that Israel and Hamas are not the only players.


Hezbollah has vowed to retaliate for the killing in Lebanon of any representative of the Iranian-backed Axis of Resistance that includes Hamas, the Yemeni Houthis, and Iraqi militias alongside the Lebanese Shiite militia and the Islamic Republic.


Members of Lebanon’s Hezbollah take part in Ashura commemorations in a southern Beirut suburb. Anwar Amro/AFP/Getty Images

 

Hezbollah has been waging a war against Israel since October 7 to tie Israeli forces down on the Jewish state’s northern border so that they cannot be deployed in Gaza without provoking an all-out conflict that could prove disastrous for Hezbollah and Lebanon.


Mr. Arouri’s killing puts Hezbollah between a rock and a hard place. It needs to find a way to be seen as living up to its vow while ensuring the hostilities do not spin out of control. Many in Lebanon fear Hamas could drag the bankrupt country into a war they do not want.


Last month, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu threatened on a visit to troops on the Lebanese border that Israel would "single-handedly turn Beirut and South Lebanon, not far from here, into Gaza and Khan Yunis" if Hezbollah started an all-out war.


In a 90-minute speech to commemorate the fourth anniversary of the US assassination of Iranian Revolutionary Guard Qassem Soleimani scheduled before Mr. Al-Arouri’s killing, Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrallah referred only summarily to the Hamas leader’s death.


Hezbollah supporters in Beirut raise their fists and cheer, as they listen to a speech by leader Hassan Nasrallah. Photo: AP

 

Much of his speech was an ode to Mr. Soleimani and Iran’s role in supporting militias in Gaza, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, and Yemen by funding, training, and arming them, enabling them to manufacture weaponry, and creating the Axis of Resistance.


Even so, Mr. Nasrallah insisted that Axis members independently took their own decisions and did not take orders from Iran.


Clad in a black cloak and turban, Mr. Nasrallah praised Hamas’ October 7 attack with no mention of the group’s targeting of civilians. He described the carnage rained on Gaza by Israel in response as “worth the sacrifice.”


The Hezbollah leader produced a laundry list of why Hamas was winning the war, including its success in putting the Palestinian plight back on the international agenda.


The war succeeded in “reviving the Palestinian cause, forcing nations across the world to look for solutions,” Mr. Nasrallah said, noting that Arab countries had been willing to establish formal relations with Israel without a resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.


Yet, the Hezbollah leader seemed to buy time, by saying he would address the issue of Lebanon and Mr. Al-Arouri’s killing in greater detail in another speech on Friday during a ceremony for a Hezbollah operative who died recently.


At the same time, Mr. Nasrallah appeared to suggest that Hezbollah would retaliate for Mr. Al-Arouri’s killing on the group’s timeline, considering widespread Lebanese opposition to a war with Israel.


Mr. Nasrallah warned, referring to Mr. Al-Arouri’s killing in the Hezbollah stronghold in southern Beirut, that “yesterday’s crime is blatant, it is serious. This crime will not go unanswered. The battlefield is there, the nights are there.”


Yet, he also noted that “we are taking the situation in Lebanon into account.”


Tellingly, Mr. Nasrallah seemed to back hardliners in Hamas’ internal debate.


Arguing that Jewish attachment to the land was fabricated and that Israelis were fleeing the country because Israel was proven incapable of providing security, Mr. Nasrallah addressed Israelis directly, saying, “Here you don’t have a future. The land of Palestine is for the Palestinians.”


Dr. James M. Dorsey is an award-winning journalist and scholar, a Senior Fellow at the National University of Singapore’s Middle East Institute and Adjunct Senior Fellow at Nanyang Technological University’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, and the author of the syndicated column and blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer.


The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


Please Subscribe




5 comentarios


It's truly a concerning situation to witness history repeating itself with the assassination of a Hamas official. Such events often have far-reaching consequences and may escalate tensions in the region. On a different note, while the situation might be tense, it's nice to know that in Toronto, Elite Livery Limousine provides top-notch limousine service, having served the GTA area with dedication for over 20 years. This kind of consistent excellence in transportation certainly adds a touch of luxury and reliability in uncertain times.

Me gusta

The cyclical nature of history becomes apparent with the recent assassination of a Hamas official, echoing a pattern of political tensions and conflicts that have persisted over time. Integrating a https://itsourheart.org/24-hour-elderly-care/ system becomes crucial, mirroring the consistent and unwavering nature of historical patterns. Regardless of external circumstances, the provision of around-the-clock care ensures the well-being of the elderly population, highlighting the cyclical nature not only of political events but also the enduring requirement for dedicated and continuous caregiving support.

Me gusta

"OptimaEquipments.com: Your Destination for High-Quality MRI and CT Scanners - Advancing Medical Imaging Technology" Introduction In the ever-evolving world of healthcare, medical imaging technology plays a pivotal role in diagnosing and treating various medical conditions. Among the most crucial equipment used in modern medical facilities are MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) and CT (Computed Tomography) scanners. These state-of-the-art machines have revolutionized medical diagnostics and significantly improved patient care. If you're in the medical field and seeking high-quality medical imaging equipment, https://optimaequipments.com/ look no further than OptimaEquipments.com. In this blog, we'll explore the features and benefits of buying MRI and CT scanners from OptimaEquipments.com. 1. A Trusted Name in Medical Imaging Equipment OptimaEquipments.com has earned a reputation as a trusted and reliable provider of medical imaging equipment.…


Me gusta

Khelraja has carved a niche for itself in the online gaming arena, and its Crash games are nothing short of a revelation. The platform has managed to capture the essence of the classic Crash experience while infusing it with the dynamic and interactive elements that define online gaming.


Me gusta

History appears to be repeating itself with the recent assassination of a Hamas official, echoing past geopolitical tensions in the region. As conflicts persist, understanding the historical context becomes crucial. Professional audiobook publishing plays a significant role in disseminating detailed narratives, analyses, and historical perspectives on the complex dynamics of the Middle East. By accessing audiobooks, individuals can delve into the intricacies of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the role of organizations like Hamas, gaining a nuanced understanding of the events that have led to the current situation.

Me gusta
bottom of page